Amazon Metadata for Books: The Hidden Risk Authors Can’t Ignore

by Penny Sansevieri | Sep 11, 2025 | Podcast for Authors

Reading Time: ( Word Count: )

Reading Time: 3 minutes

A Shocking Account Ban That Rocked the Indie Community

In a shocking revelation that has sent ripples throughout the indie author community, Penny and Amy discussed a disturbing incident where an author lost their entire catalog of 30 nonfiction books overnight due to an Amazon account ban. The ban, triggered by a single book flagged for “misleading metadata,” highlights the increasingly severe measures Amazon is taking against content that violates their guidelines—whether intentionally or unintentionally.

The author in question had been building their catalog for four years and was earning a substantial portion of their income from these books. Most distressingly, the ban resulted in the loss of pending royalty payments, effectively erasing not just future earning potential but money already earned. This cautionary tale serves as a stark reminder of how precarious an author’s position can be when relying primarily on a single retailer, especially one known for implementing sweeping policy changes without warning.

The Trigger: Metadata Missteps With Big Consequences

What makes this situation particularly concerning is the seemingly minor nature of the violation. The book that triggered the ban referenced a popular influencer in its subtitle—a practice that has been common in marketing circles but is now clearly falling under Amazon’s increased scrutiny. Even though the author had properly credited the influencer within the book, the mere mention in the metadata was deemed sufficient for a complete account ban. When the author attempted to appeal, Amazon rejected it and permanently closed the account.

This aggressive policing appears to be part of Amazon’s broader crackdown on AI-generated content flooding their marketplace. Unscrupulous operators have been uploading existing bestselling books to AI systems, having them rewritten, and then publishing these derivative works as original content. Some of these knockoffs have even mistakenly made their way onto prestigious bestseller lists like USA Today and The New York Times. While Amazon’s intent to protect intellectual property and maintain marketplace integrity is understandable, their implementation has been described by Penny as taking “a sledgehammer to what should be precision work.”

Red Flags in Amazon Metadata for Books

Authors should be particularly vigilant about several key areas that might trigger Amazon’s automated systems.

Covers that too closely resemble popular books or use cookie-cutter templates.
Subtitle abuse, especially name-dropping celebrities or public figures without permission.
Inflated claims about results, endorsements, bestseller status, or sales figures that cannot be verified.

Each of these issues connects directly to Amazon metadata for books—and can mean the difference between a successful campaign and a catastrophic ban.

Why Metadata Audits Are Essential

The podcast hosts emphasized the importance of conducting a thorough audit of your metadata—not just the keywords and categories on the backend, but also the visible elements like book descriptions, subtitles, and cover designs. They strongly advised against pushing the envelope with marketing claims, especially those that could be interpreted as misleading. While it’s important to highlight your book’s value, overpromising or making unverifiable claims is increasingly risky.

For authors concerned about their current metadata, seeking an objective third-party review was recommended. Both Penny and Amy noted that authors are often too close to their own work to objectively assess how their marketing language might be perceived. They also cautioned against relying too heavily on AI-generated content for book descriptions, as these systems tend to use inflated language that could potentially trigger Amazon’s filtering systems.

Protecting Yourself Beyond Amazon

The most important takeaway is the necessity of maintaining backups of all book files and metadata. Many authors, even experienced ones, struggle to locate their final files when needed. Additionally, building assets outside of Amazon—like a robust website and email list—provides a safety net should the worst happen. While Amazon remains the dominant player in book sales, particularly for ebooks, having the ability to reach readers directly is invaluable insurance against platform dependency.

Persistence Matters When Challenging a Ban

Despite Amazon’s stance that bans are final, both hosts encouraged persistence when dealing with enforcement actions. Documenting your case, providing evidence for any claims made in your metadata, and continually escalating issues can eventually lead to resolution. As Penny noted, “Be the toddler” who keeps asking “why” until they get a satisfactory answer.